• 2 Posts
  • 47 Comments
Joined 3 years ago
cake
Cake day: July 10th, 2023

help-circle




  • Brainsploosh@lemmy.worldtoLemmy Shitpost@lemmy.worldGet. Out
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    18
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    22 days ago

    It doesn’t reason, and it doesn’t actually know any information.

    What it excels at is giving plausible sounding averages of texts, and if you think about how little the average person knows you should be abhorred.

    Also, where people typically can reason enough to make the answer internally consistent or even relevant within a domain, LLMs offer a polished version of the disjointed amalgamation of all the platitudes or otherwise commonly repeated phrases in the training data.

    Basically, you can’t trust the information to be right, insightful or even unpoisoned, while sabotaging your strategies and systems to sift information from noise.

    EtA: All for the low low cost of personal computing, power scarcity and drought.










  • General strike, demonstrations where they can’t be ignored, organised resistance, organised campaigning, even striking in solidarity with others.

    Oh. You’re all struggling too much to be able to do that?

    That’s you being oppressed, and you could organise against that: you could organise war chests for striking, unionise to regain rights, vote or campaign for actual peoples representation rather than corporate such, build resilient communities, picket biased media, organise or join collective action, prosecute and pressure corrupt politicians, counter lobbies, educating yourself and others, etc.

    Gather neighbours, save funds, support eachother, resist where you can and coordinate with others to have a greater impact.

    But most aren’t going to, cus there’s always someone else to blame, someone else that should save the day. And while you’re passing blame, the fascists consolidate, divide and terrorise, both your domestic neighbours and international friends. Leaving you more vulnerable, more isolated, and with less and less support to resist or survive.





    1. Yes it’s your art, you used AI as a tool to create your concept, from your original ideas. If the tool is trained to reproduce others’ work (such as generative and LLM), it’s another story.

    2. A painting doesn’t belong to the brush factory nor pigment maker, but neither is the brush or the paint the artistry of it. The greys of AI tool usage is when the tool takes away the art, statement, concept and/or craftsmanship. A photographer can create art with a camera, but they can also be used for stuff that is clearly not art.

    3. To my mind, the art comes not from the school or medium, but from the artist challenging, provoking and/or expressing something human. With skill you can delve deeper within the human condition, conceptualise deeper truths, and with mastery of tools and/or craft become the better at conveying it.

    An AI, not having an understanding of human-ness can never create art, only mimic it. Studying AI art can thus surely be used as an inspiration for technique and/or reflection, but trying to replicate generated images will probably be a difficult path towards creating art.

    Then again, I would contrast art and creatives. Many ad creatives, fonts, decorations, and even wall paint swatches have very little artistic value to them, even though they require creativity and craftsmanship to realise.