• Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    2
    ·
    2 days ago

    They just want to have the ability to rip it from your library. They just want you to never have access to the games that you purchased and will never call it renting because they want to keep customers.

    We all know we’re renting by now. You don’t purchase a game, you purchase a renting term and when they make 7, they’ll remove your data from the cloud and make it impossible to play the game you paid for only for you to find out you agreed to allow them to do such.

    • Nalivai@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      2 days ago

      But here’s the kicker, having the game being sold to you on a disk does absolulely nothing to prevent that. However, while we’re talking about how amazing disks are and how much we want our games to come on 20 bucks worth of additional plastic and how much we want to pay for readers to read said plastic, we’re not talking about how much it’s legal and normal for a publisher to require you to login in their system and periodically be connected to the internet so your game can exchange whatever the fuck info with their server, or else it can’t even run (legally). Because when you buy a disk, you own a piece of expensive plastic, and files on that disk belong to the publisher just as much as the files you download from a digital store.
      Disks are dumb and it’s amazing that they’re gone, and we absolutely don’t need them to return. What we do need is the customer protection akin to stop killing games initiative, which will make digital purchase have the same legal protection as any other purchases.
      Hell, if I was a conspiratorial sort, I would say the whole disk backlash started because sony wants to misdirect the public attention

      • Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        1 day ago

        and files on that disk belong to the publisher just as much as the files you download from a digital store.

        No shit but with the disks you have indefinite access. They can’t wipe it from your system like cloud games.

        I just wish split screen and human interaction came back and owning one disk, meant 4 of your friends were coming over to beat the game.

        I wish that it wasn’t all online and that human interaction didn’t mean two people owning two systems on two tvs in the same room on gamer chairs.

        Then again… Lan parties were a thing and bringing your own computer was a thing.

        I guess with instant access and the ability to play with anyone in the world, why would you want to interact with anyone else around you.

        • Nalivai@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          23 hours ago

          No shit but with the disks you have indefinite access. They can’t wipe it from your system like cloud games.

          Disks deteriorate with use, so it’s also quite finite of an access. And even though they can’t wipe the files themselves, they can make your game unplayable just as easily as they do with ones you download. Removing DRM is just as illegal as downloading and cracked version, so you’re not getting anything here. The world where you can just install a game from disk and just play it stopped existing long ago, and unless we do something with unregulated capitalism, will never return. And the problem here not the lack of piece of plastic in your possession.
          Which leads us to the rest of your comment, which basically is a nostalgia for the times you were young. And as an old guy myself, I’m very sympathetic to your troubles. However, the return of The Disk will not help you get back to those times. You still will be a middle aged dude living isolated life in a crumbling civilization struggling to find meaning of that all.

          • Hueristic_Autistic@lemmy.world
            link
            fedilink
            English
            arrow-up
            1
            ·
            edit-2
            22 hours ago

            There’s always a way with a physical copy. You can save you data externally not connect your console and then play the game. There’s ways to get there but I suppose the forcing of someone to log in the moment you turn on the console or else the console will not work, forcing people to use the internet and pay for a membership could kill that.

            Either way, I guess I’m just an old fart that thinks that disks are cool and gives people a sense of they purchased something not just using a rental code and paying an upfront rental fee.

            Yeah I know disks won’t get us back there, those days died out long ago. The moment in person, split screen, co-op games faded out was the year everything changed and then it slowly changed human interactions. Crazy though, how it wasn’t that long ago. Like 2007-2008 it died out.

            after 2012 it really took hold and in 2013 the last of actual consoles… now we’re here, in 2026 in the current gen of ps5, switch 2 and xbox series x…almost at the cusp of the new consoles and we’re all getting fucked over by rentals.

            It’s not just nostalgia it’s knowing that it went from the death of human interaction all the way to the death of being able to own a game and play it the fuck offline.

            Honestly, the ps3, xbox one and wii u generation was the best. Those were truly entertainment systems built into gaming consoles after that they just removed features one by one.

            • Nalivai@lemmy.world
              link
              fedilink
              English
              arrow-up
              1
              ·
              21 hours ago

              The situation where you can copy files from the disk but can’t backup the same files from the game you downloaded cannot exist in this reality. Those are computers, they’re multipurpose, they can do all sorts of things. However the situation where you insert your disk, it makes loud noise and the device says that disk is unreadable is not just happens, it’s normal. And then it’s done, you don’t have your game anymore, and nobody even made any malicious decisions about it. Meanwhile your digital download you backed up is with you as long as you want, and even if publisher decides to remove the game from your device (and I can’t overstate enough how rarely that happens), those are still there.
              As for human interactions, it’s not gaming that did it to you. It’s the fact that all your friends have work in the morning, family obligations, and health issues, and their priority changed, so nobody have time or desire to hang out and play videogames all day anymore. The games are still there, and people are playing it. The interactions are still there and people are having them. We’re getting older and less active, but well, that’s nature for you. As a fellow old fart, I totally understand your angst, but well, we can’t fight time.

                • Nalivai@lemmy.world
                  link
                  fedilink
                  English
                  arrow-up
                  1
                  ·
                  4 hours ago

                  That’s the thing though, advantages of physical medium are only advantageous to very, very small subset of people, those who live somewhere where internet doesn’t exist, but who can splurge thousands of dollars on a gaming rig to play new games. Disadvantages however are hitting everyone, and they’re more numerous, from expensive equipment that you have to have, to general hassle of fiddling around with disks, to the fact that if your disk is gone you don’t have a game anymore.

    • ITGuyLevi@programming.dev
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      2 days ago

      Well thankfully the supreme court already ruled that I can keep backups… Once I buy a game I like to think I can keep it, that’s why I’ve given up on consoles though, too many people want to control the thing I bought.