• girsaysdoom@sh.itjust.works
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    2 hours ago

    But culled doesn’t have the same effect as murdered or butchered or slaughtered. Culled has the same connotation as being “put to sleep” but in reality they are typically violently gassed or suffocated and left until they die.

    That’s a massacre and if it were performed on humans, we’d call it something much worse.

    • Buddahriffic@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      1
      ·
      1 hour ago

      Not arguing that that effect isn’t real, but it’s one I just don’t get.

      To me, “cull” implies death just as much as “slaughtered”. “Butchered” isn’t even about the act of killing but the act of cutting the meat into the desired cuts (I get that it’s used in place of “killed” to imply some brutality but when talking about livestock it can make it less clear if the meat was then used or just destroyed).

      It can also just make it seem sensationalised when trying to use words that invoke a stronger emotional reaction. It only resonates with those who already agree. Like the “meat is murder” slogan will get nods from those who agree but rolled eyes from those that don’t. I just don’t think that changing the word used to describe the thing is going to make much of a difference for those that understand the meaning of the word. Just like using words like “culled” doesn’t actually downplay anything for you.

      For those that don’t understand, ok, I could see that affecting how people feel about something. Or adding those specifics about the method used and the unnecessary cruelty involved. Or specifics about the conditions that lead to scenarios where over a million birds end up getting culled. Your second sentence is a lot more convincing to me than just using the words from your first sentence.