U.S. Senator John Fetterman broke with nearly every member of his party Thursday, voting against a Democratic-backed measure seeking to end Donald Trump’s military campaign in Iran.

The Pennsylvania Democrat was the only member of his caucus to oppose the war powers resolution, which was defeated in the Senate by a vote of 48-51.

The vote put Fetterman at odds with fellow Democrats at a time when opposition to the Iran conflict has become an increasingly prominent political issue following the November midterm elections.

    • FuglyDuck@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      8
      ·
      6 hours ago

      That’s an interesting misunderstanding.

      I mean, Fetterman has broken rank and voted with republicans on every significant piece of legislation for years. I find it pretty telling that you think that means I’m saying he’s no longer a democrat.

      But no. that’s not a no true scotsman. I was commenting on his voting history.

      • wonderingwanderer@sopuli.xyz
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        3 hours ago

        I’ve noticed the “no true scotsman” thing keeps getting overused in situations where it doesn’t apply.

        I’ve noticed that happening a lot with fallacies in general. It’s like people hear them a few times, and then start saying them without understanding what they are or how to correctly identify them.

        rant

        I find it annoying as someone who regularly calls out fallacies by name, because it starts to feel watered down and cliché after people throw them around where they don’t apply.

        Like suddenly people are calling it a strawman when I disagree with them. That’s not a strawman. A strawman is when I put words in your mouth and disagree with those as if they were a point that you made. That happens all the time on lemmy, and I call it out often. But now it’s starting to feel stupid because some people default to it even when I directly address the content of what they’re saying.

        “No true scotsman” is getting the same treatment.

        Tankies gatekeeping and purity testing leftism and calling all progressives “liberals” is them doing “no true socialists scotsman.”

        People calling out a senator by name for semi-consistently siding with maga isn’t “no true democrat scotsman,” it’s just calling him out for backstabbing his constituents.