i have been daily driving GNOME recently for the first time since the pandemic.
I can see why the community is flocking to KDE. GNOME looks nice and works great with their included apps, but those apps lack a lot of basic functionality.
I ended up installing a few KDE utilities (KDE disk partition manager, Dolphin) so i wouldn’t have to keep dropping to the command line for common tasks
It’s funny I’m the complete opposite. Been using GNOME for a long-ass time, and every time I try KDE I’m left feeling underwhelmed. KDE is unstable, it’s unpolished, and lacking any sort of design direction. GNOME just kind of gets out of the way, and lets me do 95% of the things I want to do. The remaining 5% I do in a shell.
Don’t get me wrong, there are a fair few things I dislike about GNOME. Their lack of a stable extension API for one. Their bullheaded stubbornness in not adding an advanced toggle in the settings menu. The lack of compatibility with various APIs because they’ve decided to follow something to the letter, leaving some software broken.
Earlier this week I decided to reinstall the OS on my computer. Decided to give KDE another go. Haven’t been using the computer a whole lot, but there are several things off the top of my head that bothers me.
For example, people talk about KDE being very customisable, but that also comes with instability.
I’ve this bar in the top corner, which keeps disappearing on me. It comes back if I go into edit mode and add another bar to the top. Typically happens a couple of times per day. Speaking of this bar, why is it that system tray combines general system status icons and application icons into one thing? Why can’t I choose to have those separate? I’d prefer to have the application ones on a separate bar, and that’s possible so long as you go in and manually edit two bars any time a new application decides it needs tray presence.
I swapped one animation to another, and a button appeared next to the select list. Clicking this button opens up a configuration dialogue. This dialogue is clearly re-used. What I don’t get is, if you can add a button to customise this animation, could you not have just added this numerical input directly under the select element? Why is “Default” a valid number value? What value is default? Why is there a Help button that leads to nothing? Do we need six buttons in the dialogue?
This is more a personal niggle of mine, but it seems like people have forgotten what icons are for. Apple is guilty of doing this too so it’s not a KDE-specific thing. In context menus, icons aid in highlighting important options. It serves as an anchor for the attention to fall upon.
So when you have a context menu where every single entry has an icon, that just adds clutter. It doesn’t serve as an anchor, it muddles things. Someone wrote a pretty good blog post on this.
I’m also a bit eh on the lack of consistency in it. Why are 5/7 icons simple monochrome symbols and the remaining 2 full-colour detailed SVGs?
Given that it’s customisable I can just turn off icons in menus, removing the clutter. The problem is just that it shouldn’t be clutter in the first place.
The day before I reinstalled the OS on my PC my friend was struggling to find “Show hidden files” in Nautilus, I showed them where, and they criticised the design for being obtuse. I guess I see the idea of putting it where it is, with the button being a vague representation of an icon grid, and having the sub-menu handle the display of icons. I agree with my friend though, it’s not the most clear place to put it even if I understand the general idea.
That said. Literally the day after I was struggling to find the exact same thing in Dolphin, and honestly I think it’s much worse.
In Dolphin I find myself really missing Nautilus’ Sushi. I hope KDE implements something similar.
Icons are important. With just icons, people can navigate a system in a different language they aren’t proficient in. Where’s that the case? Welcome to India where everyone speaks different language (exaggeration) and most UI is in English which people speak but aren’t proficient in
My grandparents exclusively navigate via icons and speech aids on devices
So, I have been using KDE for a long time and haven’t had any stability issues, but we all have our own setup and use cases, so no point arguing on that.
For instance, I prefer when all items have icon, or if that’s not possible than no item has an icon. When only a few items have icons it looks ugly to me. And while they can’t cater for every case, I like that there are customization options for different preferences of users.
Anyway, that’s not why I am commenting, I am mainly commenting about your “Show Hidden Files” issue. I am using default dolphin setup, and it is just as simple:
as a KDE fan, I think these are valid criticisms. but just to double check on the panel disappearing, did you configure it to not disappear automatically? could it be that it reappears even when you move the mouse there?
It does not reappear when I move the mouse there. It is set to dodge windows, and at some point it just decides to leave until I threaten to replace it.
Again, it’s not about it dodging windows. That’s intended. The problem is when the desktop has no windows and the panel still refuses to return until I add a new one. I’ll record it next time it happens.
I first used KDE back in 2007, it’s not like I’m new to this.
Lmao this is very true. Yes, it is very customizable but also not published and lacks design direction.
We need more UX people in opensource communities. We need better toolings and workflows for designers to do their work. Like a Figma(or FOSS equivalent) plugin that exports a KDE global theme with a single click or something.
No I like them. It’s the mixture of both in UI elements that should use either that makes it look poorly thought through and lacking in direction.
That said, I also like the skeumorphic icons. I really miss that era of design and I’ll forever hate Apple and Google for bringing about this era of bland flat iconography. Bleh!
User interfaces are the things I like doing most in my profession, so I’m a bit anal about it.
The thing about Gnome apps, for me, is that they have 85% of the features I want with a tenth of the options KDE has. KDE has 90% of the features but 10x the options, making it messier.
But when I come up against a Gnome app being too simple, generally the KDE equivalent isn’t good enough for me either. An example being Gnome Text Editor vs Kwrite/Kate. Gnome Text Editor is fine for a simple text editor, but for more advanced things, like programming or scripting, I want to be using an IDE or *vim, not Kwrite/Kate.
I just really appreciate polish and smoothness, which Gnome has in abundance compared to KDE. And I like COSMIC for having a clean design but more pragmatic decisions than Gnome, but it’s polish and smoothness is still behind, even compared to KDE.
I’m gonna have to steal that first paragraph the next time I’m talking to someone about this. That’s a better summary of my own thoughts than I’ve ever come up with.
Every time I use Plasma, I feel like I have to dig through a thousand options about how fast the taskbar comes up or how jiggly the animations are before I find the basic option that I actually care about. Gnome feels sane by default, and the options I do want are right there.
I loved Gnome3 when it first released. I used it, love the work flow. When they changed to Wayland, discord always was glitchy. I couldn’t handle running it anymore.
I also don’t like the ideals of the devs and the constant breaking of extensions that are necessary. Like systray.
I started on GNOME when I shifted to Linux three years ago, moved to KDE about 18 months ago, and now I’m planning on moving back pretty shortly. I think GNOME’s apps are perfect as they are. They’re setup in the same way Windows and Mac are, that they’re simple but have enough functionality to cover what 95% of people need and no more. If you want more functionality then you go a find yourself a more specialised product. It feels like theirs a project manager coordinating everyone and making sure all necessary functionality is covered with little to no overlap .
KDE on the other hand, it’s just a fucking mess. It seems to be cobbled together with hobbyist software made by a bunch of people who’ve just been working on whatever they felt like doing when they woke up that morning. There’s both gaps an overlap in functionality, and a lot of it is far too advanced whilst also missing basic functionality, and a lot of it looks outright abandoned.
I just installed Zorin on my kid’s laptop, I really like it actually. I’d use it myself but it’s based on Ubuntu and I hate all that Snap bullshit.
i have been daily driving GNOME recently for the first time since the pandemic.
I can see why the community is flocking to KDE. GNOME looks nice and works great with their included apps, but those apps lack a lot of basic functionality. I ended up installing a few KDE utilities (KDE disk partition manager, Dolphin) so i wouldn’t have to keep dropping to the command line for common tasks
It’s funny I’m the complete opposite. Been using GNOME for a long-ass time, and every time I try KDE I’m left feeling underwhelmed. KDE is unstable, it’s unpolished, and lacking any sort of design direction. GNOME just kind of gets out of the way, and lets me do 95% of the things I want to do. The remaining 5% I do in a shell.
Don’t get me wrong, there are a fair few things I dislike about GNOME. Their lack of a stable extension API for one. Their bullheaded stubbornness in not adding an advanced toggle in the settings menu. The lack of compatibility with various APIs because they’ve decided to follow something to the letter, leaving some software broken.
Earlier this week I decided to reinstall the OS on my computer. Decided to give KDE another go. Haven’t been using the computer a whole lot, but there are several things off the top of my head that bothers me.
For example, people talk about KDE being very customisable, but that also comes with instability.
I’ve this bar in the top corner, which keeps disappearing on me. It comes back if I go into edit mode and add another bar to the top. Typically happens a couple of times per day. Speaking of this bar, why is it that system tray combines general system status icons and application icons into one thing? Why can’t I choose to have those separate? I’d prefer to have the application ones on a separate bar, and that’s possible so long as you go in and manually edit two bars any time a new application decides it needs tray presence.
I swapped one animation to another, and a button appeared next to the select list. Clicking this button opens up a configuration dialogue. This dialogue is clearly re-used. What I don’t get is, if you can add a button to customise this animation, could you not have just added this numerical input directly under the select element? Why is “Default” a valid number value? What value is default? Why is there a Help button that leads to nothing? Do we need six buttons in the dialogue?
This is more a personal niggle of mine, but it seems like people have forgotten what icons are for. Apple is guilty of doing this too so it’s not a KDE-specific thing. In context menus, icons aid in highlighting important options. It serves as an anchor for the attention to fall upon.
So when you have a context menu where every single entry has an icon, that just adds clutter. It doesn’t serve as an anchor, it muddles things. Someone wrote a pretty good blog post on this.
I’m also a bit eh on the lack of consistency in it. Why are 5/7 icons simple monochrome symbols and the remaining 2 full-colour detailed SVGs?
Given that it’s customisable I can just turn off icons in menus, removing the clutter. The problem is just that it shouldn’t be clutter in the first place.
The day before I reinstalled the OS on my PC my friend was struggling to find “Show hidden files” in Nautilus, I showed them where, and they criticised the design for being obtuse. I guess I see the idea of putting it where it is, with the button being a vague representation of an icon grid, and having the sub-menu handle the display of icons. I agree with my friend though, it’s not the most clear place to put it even if I understand the general idea.
That said. Literally the day after I was struggling to find the exact same thing in Dolphin, and honestly I think it’s much worse.
In Dolphin I find myself really missing Nautilus’ Sushi. I hope KDE implements something similar.
Icons are important. With just icons, people can navigate a system in a different language they aren’t proficient in. Where’s that the case? Welcome to India where everyone speaks different language (exaggeration) and most UI is in English which people speak but aren’t proficient in
My grandparents exclusively navigate via icons and speech aids on devices
So, I have been using KDE for a long time and haven’t had any stability issues, but we all have our own setup and use cases, so no point arguing on that.
For instance, I prefer when all items have icon, or if that’s not possible than no item has an icon. When only a few items have icons it looks ugly to me. And while they can’t cater for every case, I like that there are customization options for different preferences of users.
Anyway, that’s not why I am commenting, I am mainly commenting about your “Show Hidden Files” issue. I am using default dolphin setup, and it is just as simple:
as a KDE fan, I think these are valid criticisms. but just to double check on the panel disappearing, did you configure it to not disappear automatically? could it be that it reappears even when you move the mouse there?
It does not reappear when I move the mouse there. It is set to dodge windows, and at some point it just decides to leave until I threaten to replace it.
what is your plasma version? you can find it in info center. it appears to work fine in 6.8, but I haven’t tested it for long
Panel gets told to dodge windows. Panel: scoots over outside visible screen to dodge every window.
I don’t know what you’re complaining about!
Again, it’s not about it dodging windows. That’s intended. The problem is when the desktop has no windows and the panel still refuses to return until I add a new one. I’ll record it next time it happens.
I first used KDE back in 2007, it’s not like I’m new to this.
Lmao this is very true. Yes, it is very customizable but also not published and lacks design direction.
We need more UX people in opensource communities. We need better toolings and workflows for designers to do their work. Like a Figma(or FOSS equivalent) plugin that exports a KDE global theme with a single click or something.
I still dont understand what people have against KDE’s monochrome icons, they are so cute, and crisp I love them
No I like them. It’s the mixture of both in UI elements that should use either that makes it look poorly thought through and lacking in direction.
That said, I also like the skeumorphic icons. I really miss that era of design and I’ll forever hate Apple and Google for bringing about this era of bland flat iconography. Bleh!
User interfaces are the things I like doing most in my profession, so I’m a bit anal about it.
The thing about Gnome apps, for me, is that they have 85% of the features I want with a tenth of the options KDE has. KDE has 90% of the features but 10x the options, making it messier.
But when I come up against a Gnome app being too simple, generally the KDE equivalent isn’t good enough for me either. An example being Gnome Text Editor vs Kwrite/Kate. Gnome Text Editor is fine for a simple text editor, but for more advanced things, like programming or scripting, I want to be using an IDE or *vim, not Kwrite/Kate.
I just really appreciate polish and smoothness, which Gnome has in abundance compared to KDE. And I like COSMIC for having a clean design but more pragmatic decisions than Gnome, but it’s polish and smoothness is still behind, even compared to KDE.
I’m gonna have to steal that first paragraph the next time I’m talking to someone about this. That’s a better summary of my own thoughts than I’ve ever come up with.
Every time I use Plasma, I feel like I have to dig through a thousand options about how fast the taskbar comes up or how jiggly the animations are before I find the basic option that I actually care about. Gnome feels sane by default, and the options I do want are right there.
I loved Gnome3 when it first released. I used it, love the work flow. When they changed to Wayland, discord always was glitchy. I couldn’t handle running it anymore.
I also don’t like the ideals of the devs and the constant breaking of extensions that are necessary. Like systray.
I started on GNOME when I shifted to Linux three years ago, moved to KDE about 18 months ago, and now I’m planning on moving back pretty shortly. I think GNOME’s apps are perfect as they are. They’re setup in the same way Windows and Mac are, that they’re simple but have enough functionality to cover what 95% of people need and no more. If you want more functionality then you go a find yourself a more specialised product. It feels like theirs a project manager coordinating everyone and making sure all necessary functionality is covered with little to no overlap .
KDE on the other hand, it’s just a fucking mess. It seems to be cobbled together with hobbyist software made by a bunch of people who’ve just been working on whatever they felt like doing when they woke up that morning. There’s both gaps an overlap in functionality, and a lot of it is far too advanced whilst also missing basic functionality, and a lot of it looks outright abandoned.
I just installed Zorin on my kid’s laptop, I really like it actually. I’d use it myself but it’s based on Ubuntu and I hate all that Snap bullshit.
Did “disks” not work for you?