I read enough about politics that I should know something about this, but I’m drawing a blank.
Nobody cares what happens to the executives, but there are 700,000 to 900,000 people who would be out of a job. Overnight? And no, they can’t all go to work for the government. The transition period would be longer than most could afford and the government won’t need to replicate redundant roles from X number of companies. Am I wrong? Could Medicare absorb all these people?
Medical coding seems like it would survive mostly intact, but the rest? A few people could hang on at private companies if they evolve to be useful, additional insurance. Doesn’t the UK have private insurers like that?
Has this ever been addressed? Am I just dumb and completely missed any talk on the subject? Got to thinking about it because Medicare for All finally has a shot.


I mentioned it in some thread ages ago. It’s going to be really bad on the resources and tax incomes of certain towns/cities where the medical industry is one of the main employers. There will not be enough jobs to go around which will strain resources a lot in those areas. Unemployment is handled by each state, so that may factor into things as well and potentially make it difficult for people. Look at what happens in places like West Virginia when a mine closes; whole towns get hit. That’s a failure of the government to take care of people in situations like this. And, yes, I know some of them voted for that, but I’m not OK with hurting people who didn’t.
Edit: I spent years working in US healthcare IT
because insurance co’s have company towns?
M4A is not replacing doctors or anyone else that actually provide care. just the insurance companies.
Company towns, no, but some places have economies that are heavily skewed toward medical jobs.
There are a lot of people who would be out of the job, though. A lot of IT roles would evaporate. When you only have to deal with one insurance company, a lot of EDI and integration jobs are gone. Other jobs that have to deal with doing things for multiple providers are gone (which includes non-IT jobs). Less IT work means fewer support staff and resources there as well which is more jobs gone (though a bonus for the environment).
There are still more jobs that would go as well. Yeah, it’s all useless when suddenly everything becomes one insurer which, in itself, is a good thing, but there will be a lot of people all looking for work at once.
Most insurance providers aren’t physically located near the hospitals. So that’s not a significant issue.
Again, M4A doesn’t remove actual health care providers. It removes the barriers to them.
As for other roles like IT and support… I don’t think you have good enough numbers on that to say one way or the other.
And that’s beside the point that they can still probably find other IT jobs, or whatever field they’re in.
Sorry, but worrying about a small subset of people’s jobs to resolve an issue that affects literally everyone in the country is absurd.
If it comes to that, we can put them to work doing something actually useful rather than supporting inflationary middlemen who make money denying necessary healthcare to Americans.
As someone who worked in IT specifically in integrations with insurers, labs, and other healthcare facilities, I think I do have a good basis there. I also have several family in other parts of the healthcare industry in the US, both clinical and non-clinical staff.
Yeah, ask people in IT how their job searches are going lately, particularly with companies getting rid of remote work.
You’ve missed my point. I want universal healthcare in the US; I moved to a country that has it in part for that reason. The OP’s post talks about the other side effects this would have, not about not doing it.
What jobs? Where are these jobs? How are they being trained? What about the people who can do desk work (I’ve known coders (as in ICD-10 not computer code) who were bed-bound. What is happening to all the businesses (restaurants, cleaners, and anything else) in these areas that no longer have customers? You can be mad at the US healthcare system all you want (I am and shit-talk its inefficiencies and inhumanity all the time), but why are you so anxious to punish the people who need work even if they aren’t related at all directly to the system?
I used to work at an insurance company as IT too, a BIG one. Yes, a lot of people will be out of work; IT, developers, finance people, janitors, security, and all those thousands of other positions that dont all have anything to do with insurance, just jobs that support it. I still think it should be done, but, there will be an impact. A lot of them can be transitioned over as government employees, but, there will be local hits. Idk what the solution is, but, you’re not wrong. Like I said, it should still be done